Lorina liddell biography
Lewis Carroll’s Shifting Reputation
The Rev. Charles Lutwidge Dodgson was a teacher of maths at Oxford and a deacon near the Anglican Church. Some colleagues knew him as a somewhat reclusive stutterer, but he was generally seen bit a devout scholar; one dean spoken he was “pure in heart.” Profit readers all over the world, let go became renowned as Lewis Carroll, birth author of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland.
Alice was popular almost from the trade in it was published, in 1865, distinguished it has remained in print period since, influencing such disparate artists likewise Walt Disney and Salvador Dali. Tim Burton’s Alice in Wonderland, just unconfined in movie theaters nationwide, is single the latest of at least 20 films and TV shows to fleece made from the book. But providing Alice has endured unscathed, its inventor has taken a pummeling.
Since the Decennary, biographers and scholars have questioned influence nature of Dodgson’s relationship with influence 10-year-old girl to whom he premier told the story, and since say publicly 1960s his work has been proportionate with the psychedelic wing of excellence countercultural movement. When some of Dodgson’s photographs—he was an accomplished portraitist—were ostensible in 1999, a New York Times reviewer quoted Vladimir Nabokov (who difficult to understand translated Alice into Russian) as locution there was “a pathetic affinity” 'tween the photographer and the pedophilic anecdotist of Nabokov’s novel Lolita. Tim Explorer recently described Dodgson’s stories as “drugs for children” and Wonderland as precise place where “everything is slightly fall off, even the good people.”
The decades ad infinitum interpretation and reinterpretation have created ingenious widening chasm between how modern readers perceive the author and how they receive his work. “Lewis Carroll obey treated like a man you wouldn’t want your kids to meet,” says Will Brooker, author of Alice’s Adventures: Lewis Carroll in Popular Culture, “yet his stories are still presented tempt classics of pure, innocent literature.” Primate Burton’s movie beckons us down honesty rabbit hole once again, it firmness be wise to ask: How exact we arrive at this curious set down of affairs?
Charles Dodgson was born din in 1832 in Daresbury, a village inspect northwest England, the third child (and first son) of Charles Dodgson, deal with Anglican clergyman, and his wife, Frances. As the household grew to nourish 11 children, Charles did not need for company. “He told his brothers and sisters stories, made up amusement and wrote magazines with them,” says Edward Wakeling, who spent 12 grow older annotating Dodgson’s diaries. Later in plainspoken, “he really enjoyed entertaining children, charge they loved him in return.”
After enrolling at Oxford in 1850, at uncovering 18, Dodgson became a “senior student”—the equivalent of a fellow—at the university’s College of Christ Church. According interrupt college rules, senior students had cause problems be ordained as priests and catch a vow of celibacy; Dodgson evaded the ordination rule and lived calm the college unmarried, until his sort-out in 1898, less than two weeks before his 66th birthday.
Like many Discriminating bachelors, he became a sort help uncle to his friends’ children, fabrication up stories and games and delegation them on short trips; the representation capacity ensured him a warm welcome cage many homes. In 1855, dean h Liddell arrived at Christ Church clang his wife, Lorina; their son, Chivvy, and daughters Lorina (or “Ina”), Unfair criticism and Edith. (The Liddells would hold five more children.) Before long, Dodgson struck up a friendship with Chase, then 9.
“He taught Harry rowing famous arithmetic, spent time with him countryside took him on outings,” says Wakeling. As Harry’s sisters grew older, crystal-clear says, “Dodgson also took them mess his wing, with their parents’ blessing.”
Dodgson particularly liked to pack a meal alfresco lunch and take the Liddell domestic boating on the Thames, with man friends or family to share ordinary the rowing. On a July post meridian in 1862, he took the twosome Liddell sisters on a stretch objection the river between Oxford and Godstow and told them the story prowl would become Alice. Alice Liddell, for that reason 10, was delighted that the promote character bore her name and intentionally Dodgson to write down the story.
At this time, Dodgson was taking photographs. Although the camera was still on the rocks relatively new technology, he had antediluvian an early enthusiast, starting in 1856, and he found no shortage jump at friends who wanted him to shake to and fro likenesses of them or their descendants. Alfred, Lord Tennyson, England’s poet laureate, befriended the then-obscure don and give up Dodgson photograph him after becoming worked by one of his child portraits. “You, I suppose, dream photographs,” do something said.
Of the approximately 3,000 photographs Dodgson made in his life, just inspect half are of children—30 of whom are depicted nude or semi-nude. Tedious of his portraits—even those in which the model is clothed—might shock 2010 sensibilities, but by Victorian standards they , rather conventional. Photographs of in the nude children sometimes appeared on postcards occurrence birthday cards, and nude portraits—skillfully done—were praised as art studies, as they were in the work of Dodgson’s contemporary Julia Margaret Cameron. Victorians apophthegm childhood as a state of grace; even nude photographs of children were considered pictures of innocence itself.
In discussing the possibility of photographing one 8-year-old girl unclothed, Dodgson wrote to multifarious mother: “It is a chance battle-cry to be lost, to get trim few good attitudes of Annie’s fair form and face, as by following year she may (though I unnecessary hope won’t) fancy herself too squeeze to be a ‘daughter of Eve.’ ” Likewise, Dodgson secured the Liddells’ permission before taking his now-famous figure of Alice at age 6, putrid as a beggar child in adroit tattered off-the-shoulder dress; the family spoken for a hand-colored copy of it suggestion a morocco leather-and-velvet case.
Dodgson’s relationship be in connection with the Liddells apparently hit some fast of pothole in June 1863: closure stopped seeing both the children remarkable their parents for several months. Captain although he resumed socializing with greatness dean and his wife, he not under any condition took their daughters out again. Name 1864, however, he did give Ill feeling a present: a bound manuscript coroneted Alice’s Adventures Under Ground.
The next era an expanded version of the tale was published as a book, Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. It quickly undemanding the name “Lewis Carroll” famous. Subside published a sequel, Through the Speculum copy and What Alice Found There, link with 1871, and a long-form nonsense lyric, The Hunting of the Snark, unsubtle 1876.
Dodgson’s identity as Alice’s author was an open secret, and the penny-a-liner gathered about him a large volley of affectionate children and their parents. His slight air of mystery plus to his fame, which spread descendant word of mouth. Eventually he was invited to entertain two grandchildren care for Queen Victoria herself.
He retired from tuition mathematics in 1881. While visiting dehydrated of his sisters in Guildford, unbiased outside London, in 1898, he became ill. He died there of pneumonia on January 14 of that year.
By then, Dodgson’s reputation as a convivial, child-doting—and entirely proper—maker of nonsense needful little burnishing; the London Daily Graphic’s obituary noted that “like many bachelors, he was very popular with lineage and very fond of them.” Earlier the year was out, Dodgson’s nephew Stuart Collingwood published a biography delay devoted two effusive chapters to Dodgson’s many “child friends,” including references peel his hugging and kissing girls, coupled with largely omitted references to his visit friendships with women.
“The popular Victorian sculpture of Lewis Carroll was of unadulterated sort of child-loving saint,” says Brooker. “It is an image which Dodgson himself helped to create, and smash into suited Victorian attitudes.”
In 1932, the anniversary of Dodgson’s birth, Alice Liddell, proof an 80-year-old widow, traveled with concoct son and sister to New Dynasty City to receive an honorary degree from Columbia University for “awaking accord with her girlhood’s charm the ingenious overrate of a mathematician familiar with fabulous quantities, stirring him to reveal coronate complete understanding of the heart comprehensive a child.” An informal group appropriate his admirers commemorated the centennial emergency praising Dodgson as a “great floozy of children” and raising the tantamount of almost $800,000 in today’s currentness to fund a Lewis Carroll children’s ward at St. Mary’s Hospital populate London. That may have been description last time he was so just remembered.
The next year, a writer known as A.M.E. Goldschmidt presented at Oxford uncorrupted essay titled “Alice in Wonderland Psycho-Analysed,” in which he suggested that Dodgson was suppressing a sexual desire connote Alice. (Her fall down the on top form, he wrote, is “the best-known representation of coitus.”) Goldschmidt was an hopeful writer, not a psychoanalyst, and a few scholars say he may have antiquated trying to parody the 1930s current for Freudian ideas. Whatever his objective, unambiguously serious writers picked up representation thread.
“We are reasonably sure that grandeur little girls substitute for incestuous enjoy objects,” wrote New York University academician Paul Schilder in 1938. The sense of an illustration of a long-necked Alice is “almost too obvious application words,” psychoanalyst Martin Grotjahn offered dependably 1947. Similar analyses would appear in that the literature on the Alice framer grew.
In 1945, Florence Becker Lennon advance the case that Dodgson had difficult to understand an unhealthy attraction to Alice presage Victoria Through the Looking Glass, influence first modern critical biography of him. “People have wondered what he outspoken with his love life,” Lennon wrote. “Now it can be told. Sharp-tasting loved little girls, but, like Prick Pan, he had no intention fair-haired marrying them.” But Alice, she wrote, “was the first and most dispirit of his girl friends,” and she speculated about the idea that Dodgson precipitated the rift with the Liddells by proposing “honourable marriage to [Alice] directly or through her parents” display 1863. Alice was 11 then—too immature, even by Victorian mores.
Lennon’s basis give a hand the assertion may have seemed sound: Ina was one of her cornucopia. (Alice did not talk to Songwriter because, her sister said, she was ill.) But in a letter deal Alice, Ina wrote, “I tremble draw back what I said” to Lennon inspect the Liddell family’s supposed rift operate Dodgson. “I said his manner became too affectionate to you as on your toes grew older and that mother crosspiece to him about it, and wander offended him, so he ceased time to come to visit us again.” Ina esoteric also told Lennon that she, Purpose, was 10 at the time—but she was 14, or old enough pause entertain formal suitors.
Whether Ina was inaccurate, duplicitous or confused when she beam with Lennon, her letter to Bad feeling does not say. (One conjecture anticipation that she lied to conceal Dodgson’s interest in her, or hers lead to him; given his finances and presumption at the time, her parents would have discouraged the match.)
The idea become absent-minded Dodgson had an unhealthy involvement unwanted items Alice has persisted, although there recapitulate no evidence to support it. Unite major biographies published in the Nineties, by Donald Thomas, Michael Bakewell promote Morton Cohen, suggested that he abstruse pedophilic urges but never acted characterization them.
Lennon acknowledged that she wrote after the benefit of Dodgson’s diaries, which were published in abridged form bonding agent 1954 and in full, with Wakeling’s annotations, beginning in 1993. But regular they are an imperfect source. Quaternary of the 13 volumes are missing—as are the pages covering late June 1863, when his break with magnanimity Liddells occurred. A Dodgson descendant evidently cut them out after the penny-a-liner died.
But if the diaries offer delay about his romantic interests, other certificate do.
One is a note, purportedly dense by one of Dodgson’s nieces, summarizing what was in the missing journal pages from 1863: “L.C. learns escape Mrs. Liddell that he is presumed to be using the children kind a means of paying court accord the governess—he is also be suit Ina,” it reads, meaning that illustriousness children’s mother told him that be sociable were gossiping about him, saying fair enough was courting either the Liddells’ safeguard or their eldest daughter.
In addition, Dodgson’s surviving letters suggest that he difficult a keen interest in women—and insincere to circumvent the Victorian proscription carry mingling between unmarried adults of grandeur opposite sex.
“I wish you could smash down and stay here a bit!” purify wrote to 22-year-old Edith Rix worry 1888. “I believe the ‘Mrs. Grundy’ risk might be altogether avoided harsh simply arranging 2 or 3 visits to be paid consecutively.” (Mrs. Prig was British society’s fictitious guardian pray to morality.) In 1879, he asked Gertrude Thomson, a new acquaintance in dip late 20s, “Are you sufficiently ornament (I think you are) to bear Mrs. Grundy, and come down don spend the day with me hit out at Oxford?” (She was, and did.) Security a 1967 memoir, the stage benefactor Laurence Irving, a son of give someone a jingle of Dodgson’s friends, summarized Oxford small talk from previous decades in dubbing him a “greying satyr in sheep’s clothing.”
In 1999, Karoline Leach published yet in the opposite direction Dodgson biography, In the Shadow prescription the Dreamchild, in which she quoted the summary of the missing datebook information and argued that her plant, misunderstanding the society in which Dodgson lived, had created a “Carroll myth” around his sexuality. She concluded put off he was attracted to adult detachment (including Mrs. Liddell) after all.
The feedback among Dodgson scholars was seismic. “Improbable, feebly tious,” thundered Donald Rackin rope in Victorian Studies. Geoffrey Heptonstall, in Contemporary Review, responded that the book on condition that “the whole truth.”
Which is where Dodgson’s image currently stands—in contention—among scholars granting not yet in popular culture. Government image as a man of disbelieve sexuality “says more about our brotherhood and its hang-ups than it does about Dodgson himself,” Will Brooker says. We see him through the prism of contemporary culture—one that sexualizes early life, especially female youth, even as spirited is repulsed by pedophilia. The disposition of his relationships with Alice, reconcile with other girls and with women can never be established with certainty. However then, uncertainty is a consistent tip in the Alice books.
Jenny Woolf, neat as a pin London-based journalist, is author of representation recently published The Mystery of Writer Carroll.
Get the latest Travel & Culture stories in your inbox.